Even The King Struggles..!
When I say King I mean It..It is easy to see why.. Alphonso Mango's voluptuous shape, sunshine yellow skin reveals saffron colored, smooth flesh...imagine an impeccable cross between peach, nectarine, apricot, melon with notes of honey and citrus..Alphonso is better than you imagined..! Alphonso becomes an obsessive passion not only for its producers but also for the consumers when it hits the market during the season.
Now coming back from the poetic yet real description of the King to the struggle it faces. Last season Alphonso suffered a major setback in the export market. I will not delve into the details of it since it has been discussed widely in media. What I would like to share is that Alphonso being a King of Mangoes is struggling to get a Geographical Indications tag in India...
Going by the facts there are three applicants who have sough to register Alphonso Mango as the Geographical Indication, namely- Konkan Krishi Vidyapeeth (Appl. No. 139), Devgad Taluka Amba Utpadak Sahakari Sanstha Maryadit (Appl. No. 379), and Kelshi Parisar Amba Utpadak Sahakari Sanstha Maryadit (Appl. No. 497).
Appl. No. 139 seeks protection of Alphonso Mango on a wide GI area which includes few districts of Gujarat, Konkan region of Maharashtra, North Karnataka and State of Goa.
Appl. No. 379 seeks protection of Devgad cultivar of Alphonso Mango covering Devgad Taluk as GI area.
Appl. No. 497 seeks protection of Ratnagiri cultivar of Alphonso Mango covering Ratnagiri District as GI area.
Now, the conflict arises whom to grant what?? If Appl. No. 139 gets registration then Alphonso as a whole gets generalized protection on the sought GI area. If Appl. No. 379 & 497 get registration, then the name Alphonso becomes generic nomenclature according to many.
Alors! Traditional and scientific facts tell us something else. Alphonso derived its name from Afonso de Albuquerque, the Portuguese explorer. He led the Portuguese invasion into India in the 1600s and therein the Portuguese introduced the Mango variety through grafts on Mango trees. Starting its journey in Goa, the Alphonso Mango traveled across the Western India. Later it became the treasure fiercely guarded by the locals. It can be observed that significant variation exists, among trees of the same clone in an orchard w.r.t. fruit shape, size, color, and quality ascribed to bud mutation. The generic divergence could be attributed to the differences in environmental and geographical conditions.
M.D. Manchekar et al, Clonal variability studies in Alphonso Mango (Mangifera indica L.) by genetic divergence (D2) analysis, Karnataka J. Agri. Sci., 24(4):(490-492) 2011, evaluated nine location specific clones of Alphonso were used for testing divergence by employing Mahalanobis D2 analysis. [The clones are named as: DPL-I (Dapoli), RTN-1 (Ratnagiri), DVG-I (Devgad), VEN-I (Vengurla), DWR-I, II, III (Dharwad), BGM-I, II (Belgaum).]
Following are the divergence values of intra and inter cluster distance-
Given this genetic divergence, one can easily see that there are fundamental differences between the different clones of Alphonso Mango.
In my opinion, different cultivars of Alphonso Mango who have established uniqueness and have geographical significance to that deserve a separate geographical indication protection.
Let's hope that the King won't be trapped in the never ending dispute just like the Basmati Rice where Madhya Pradesh and the Basmati growers therein are fighting for the inclusion of Madhya Pradesh in the application submitted by APEDA.
LONG LIVE KING OF MANGOES..!!
- until next time...
Comments
Post a Comment